Legal Ethics Roundup: AG James Indicted, Golden Gate Law Returns, No Discipline For Law Firm Trump Pro Bono Deals & More – Above the Law



Ed.
note
:
Please
welcome
Renee
Knake
Jefferson
back
to
the
pages
of
Above
the
Law.
Subscribe
to
her
Substack,
Legal
Ethics
Roundup, here.


Welcome
to
what
captivates,
haunts,
inspires,
and
surprises
me
every
week
in
the
world
of
legal
ethics.

Join
me
LIVE
this
week
at
the
University
of
Houston’s
virtual
program “Lawyers
Who
Lead:
Ethics,
Influence,
and
Impact” 
on
Thursday
10/16
from
3-5PM
central.
Learn
more
and
register here.
Other
speakers
include H.
Stephen
Grace
Jr. 
(President
and
Founder
H.S.
Grace
&
Co.)
and Andrew
Gratz 
(Founder
of
the
Initiative
on
Lawyers
as
Leaders).


Now
for
your
headlines. 


Highlights
from
Last
Week –
Top
Ten
Headlines


#1
“Court
Leans
Toward
Allowing
Trial
Judges
to
Limit
Attorney-Client
Discussions
During
Overnight
Recesses.” 
From SCOTUSBlog: “At
least
some
of
the
justices
at
Monday
morning’s
oral
argument
in Villarreal
v.
Texas
 
appear
to
be
willing
to
permit
trial
courts
to
limit
what
defense
lawyers
may
discuss
with
their
clients
overnight
when
the
client
is
still
on
the
stand.
Specifically,
several
justices
seem
to
think
the
court
may
prohibit
lawyer
and
client
from
direct
discussions
of
the
client’s
testimony,
but
not
collateral
matters
of
trial
strategy
and
management
that
relate
to
the
testimony.”
Read
more here.
(Full
disclosure:
Along
with
several
other
legal
ethics
scholars, I
joined
an
amicus
brief
 in
this
matter.)


#2
“C.I.A.
Deputy
Director
Has
Replaced
Agency’s
Top
Legal
Official
With
Himself.” 
From The
New
York
Times: 
“It
was
not
clear
what
was
behind [Michael]
Ellis’s
 taking
personal
control
of
making
legal
judgments
for
the
agency
while
continuing
to
help
lead
it,
but
the
move
raised
alarms
among
some
current
and
former
intelligence
officials. Stephen
Gillers
,
a
New
York
University
professor
of
legal
ethics,
called
the
arrangement
‘rather
bizarre.’
Pointing
to
rules
of
professional
conduct
for
lawyers
that
prohibit
conflicts
of
interest,
he
said
Mr.
Ellis
could
serve
as
C.I.A.
general
counsel
for
matters
in
which
he
had
no
interest,
but
could
not
ethically
give
himself
legal
advice
about
issues
that
concern
him

including
whether
policy
actions
he
wants
to
take
would
be
lawful.”
Read
more here (gift
link).


#3
“Law
Firms’
Trump
Deals
Escape
NY
Lawyer
Ethics
Investigation.” 
From Bloomberg
Law: 
“A
disciplinary
body
for
New
York
lawyers
is
putting
off
an
ethics
probe
into
major
law
firms’
deals
with President
Donald
Trump
.
A
New
York
Supreme
Court
committee
last
month
declined
to
take
up
a
complaint
against
nine
firms
that
pledged
nearly
$1
billion
in
free
legal
services
to
White
House
in
exchange
for
the
removal
of
administrative
probes
and
punishments,
according
to
documents
obtained
by
Bloomberg
Law.
The
complaint,
filed
by
a
group
of
law
professors,
accused
the
firms
of
violating
ethics
rules
by
‘capitulating’
to
Trump’s
‘bullying.’
‘The
business
decisions
of
law
firms,
such
as
the
selection
of
clients
or
the
allocation
of
pro
bono
resources,
generally
fall
outside
the
purview
of
this
Committee,’ Jorge
Dopico
,
chief
attorney
for
the
committee,
said
in
a
Sept.
2
letter.”
Read
more here.


#4
“New
Law
Lets
California
Law
Students
Be
Paid
for
For-Credit
Externships.” 
From
the California
Lawyer
 Daily
Journal: 
“What
started
as
a
student
brainstorming
session
in
a
Sacramento
classroom
has
now
become
California
law.
On
Friday, Gov.
Gavin
Newsom
signed
AB
1155,
legislation
requiring
law
schools
across
the
state
to
allow
students
to
be
paid
for
professional
externships
even
while
earning
academic
credit.”
Read
more here.


#5
“Retired
Justice
Kennedy
Laments
Coarse
Discourse
of
Trump
Era
and
Its
Effects
on
the
Supreme
Court.” 
From
the Associated
Press: 
“Retired Supreme
Court
Justice
Anthony
Kennedy
 said
Wednesday
he
was
troubled
that
partisanship
seemed
to
be
‘creeping
its
way
into
the
court,’
and
that
the
state
of
political
discourse
in
the
country
has
gotten
so
vulgar
and
vile
that
he
worries
for
the
country.
The
tone
of
recent
opinions
bothers
him
more
than
outcomes
of
cases,
Kennedy
said
in
an
interview
with
The
Associated
Press
in
his
court
office
in
advance
of
next
week’s
publication
of
his
memoir, Life,
Law
&
Liberty
.
‘The
justices
have
to
resist
thinking
of
themselves
as
being
partisan,’
he
said.
‘In
our
current
discourse,
it
seems
to
me,
partisanship
is
creeping
its
way
into
the
court.’”
Read
more here.


#6
“How
Letitia
James
Will
Do
Her
Day
Job.” 
From The
New
York
Times: 
Letitia
James
 is
New
York’s
chief
legal
officer,
leading
an
office
of
1,700
people,
including
800
lawyers.
And
now
she’s
a
criminal
defendant.
After
Ms.
James,
who
has
been
New
York’s
attorney
general
since
2018,
was
indicted
on
Thursday
on
federal
charges
of
bank
fraud
and
false
statements,
she
vowed
to
keep
doing
her
job
leading
one
of
the
country’s
largest
prosecutor’s
offices.
The
case’s
impact
on
her
job
will
be
‘zero,’
said James
E.
Tierney
,
a
former
Maine
attorney
general
who
teaches
about
the
position
at
Harvard
Law
School.
It
is
not
the
first
time
that
an
attorney
general
has
been
indicted
and
continued
to
lead,
Mr.
Tierney
said.
Stephen
Gillers
,
a
legal
ethics
expert
at
New
York
University’s
School
of
Law,
said
that
ethical
guidelines
would
not
require
Ms.
James
to
recuse
herself
from
those
cases.”
Read
more here (gift
link).
And
for additional
commentary
 on
the
indictment,
see
this
op-ed
from Richard
Zitrin
 (UC
San
Francisco)
in
the San
Francisco
Chronicle
:
“With
the
Letitia
James
indictment,
Trump’s
politics
of
revenge
threaten
to
rewrite
justice
in
America.” Read
more here.


#7
“Golden
Gate
University
Seeks
California
Accreditation
to
Reopen
Law
School.” 
From Reuters: “The
Golden
Gate
University
is
aiming
to
revive
the
troubled
law
school
it
closed
last
year,
reopening
it
as
a
California-accredited
institution.
The
San
Francisco-based
university
has
asked
the
State
Bar
of
California
for
accreditation

which
would
enable
Juris
Doctor
graduates
of
the
school
to
sit
for
the
bar
in
California
but
not
in
most
other
states.
The
state
bar’s
Committee
of
Bar
Examiners
is
due
to
consider
the
university’s
application
on
Friday.”
Read
more here.


#8
“Independence
First:
An
Ethical
Test
for
Litigation
Funding.” 
From Bailey
Glasser: 
“Of
the
handful
of
ethics
authorities
that
have
issued
opinions
directly
addressing
litigation
financing,
one
issue
remains
paramount:
attorney
control
of
litigation
and
independence
in
attorney
judgment.
Although
ethics
bodies
apply
varying
ethics
rules
to
address
the
pertinent
issues,
a
common
theme
between
them
is
an
emphasis
that
funding
agreements
will
be
impermissible
if
they
imperil
or
restrict
attorney
independence.
Below
are
highlights
from
a
few
of
the
states
that
have
addressed
the
issue
and
prioritize
the
importance
of
protecting
attorney
independence.”
Read
more here.


#9
“Lawyer
AI
Competence:
Training
Is
Becoming
Mandatory

But
Lawyers
Still
Get
Burned.” 
From Attorney
at
Work: 
“If
you
think
knowing
something
about
artificial
intelligence
is
optional
for
lawyers,
think
again.
A
growing
number
of
U.S.
law
schools
have
decided
that
AI
training
is
not
a
luxury
or
an
elective

it
is
becoming
a
requirement.
Meanwhile,
lawyers
continue
to
face
discipline
or
fines
because
they
lack
basic
AI
competence.
The
contrast
couldn’t
be
more
stark:
Students
are
being
taught
the
rules
while
practicing
lawyers
are
still
struggling
to
understand
them.”
Read
more here.


#10
“Deepfakes,
Data,
and
Duty:
Navigating
AI
Ethics
in
Law,
with
Merisa
Bowers.” 
From Lawyerist
Podcast: 
Zack
Glaser
 talks
with Merisa
Bowers
,
Loss
Prevention
and
Outreach
Counsel
at
the
Ohio
Bar
Liability
Insurance
Company,
about
how
artificial
intelligence
is
reshaping
lawyers’
ethical
duties.
Merisa
explains
how
deepfakes
and
realistic
scams
are
creating
new
challenges
for
diligence
and
verification,
why
unregulated
chatbots
can
accidentally
create
attorney-client
relationships,
and
what
disclosures
lawyers
should
make
when
using
AI
tools.
She
also
shares
practical
steps
to
maintain
confidentiality,
protect
client
data,
and
apply
long-standing
ethics
rules
to
fast-changing
technologies.”
Read
more here.


Get
Hired

Did
you
miss
the
350+
job
postings
from
previous
weeks?
Find
them
all here.


Upcoming
Ethics
Events
&
Other
Announcements

Did
you
miss
an
announcement
from
previous
weeks?
Find
them
all here.


Keep
in
Touch


  • News
    tips?
    Announcements?
    Events?
     A
    job
    to
    post?
     Reading
    recommendations?
     Email [email protected] –
    but
    be
    sure
    to
    subscribe
    first,
    otherwise
    the
    email
    won’t
    be
    delivered.



Renee
Knake
Jefferson
holds
the
endowed
Doherty
Chair
in
Legal
Ethics
and
is
a
Professor
of
Law
at
the
University
of
Houston.
Check
out
more
of
her
writing
at
the Legal
Ethics
Roundup
.
Find
her
on
X
(formerly
Twitter)
at @reneeknake or
Bluesky
at legalethics.bsky.social

Morning Docket: 10.14.25 – Above the Law

*
Barack
Obama
weighs
in
on
capitulating
law
firms.
[The
Hill
]

*
A
look
at
the
lawyers
giving
up
big
money
to
challenge
the
administration.
[The
New
Republic
]

*
Lawyers
discover
AI
produces
little
time
savings.
[Bloomberg
Law
News
]

*
Totally
serious
and
not-at-all
frivolous

lawsuit
against
Michigan
Law
Review

dropped.
[Reuters]

*
Donna
Adelson
gets
life
sentence.
[CNN]

*
AI
artist
asks
Supreme
Court
for
copyright
protection.
[Law.com]

*
Trump
business
partner
liable
in
money
laundering
scheme.
[Law360]

Magically Disappearing Partners – See Generally – Above the Law

Who?
Never
Heard
Of
‘Em:
Kirkland
decides
not
to
name
the
new
partners.
Disappearing
Lawyers
The
Old
Fashioned
Way:
Cadwalader
loses
nearly
40
in
raid.
DOJ
Gets
Creative:
And
annoys
judge
in
the
process.
We
Expect
Fake
History,
But
This
Is
Ridiculous!:
Federal
judges
asked
to
explain
how
fake
cites
ended
up
in
their
opinions.
We’re
Not
Saying
They’re
Connected,
But…:
Judge’s
home
burns
down
after
she
ruled
against
Trump
administration
and
Stephen
Miller
told
the
faithful
that
judges
are
shielding
terrorists.
I
Used
To
Bullseye
Womprats:
Harvard
Law
professor
arrested
after
going
rat
hunting.
Don’t
Take
The
Brown
Acid:
Deloitte
caught
issuing
report
with
AI
hallucinations.

Full Details Of Chiwenga’s Politburo Presentation On 17 September 2025

2.
Comrade
President,
in
November
2017,
we
took
a
bold
and
necessary
step
to
remove
former
President
Robert
Mugabe
from
power,
because:

  • he
    sought
    to
    manipulate
    our
    Constitution
    for
    personal
    gain.
  • he
    allowed
    certain
    individuals
    and
    family
    to
    seize
    his
    executive
    authority
    and
    abuse
    it.
  • he
    ignored
    the
    suffering
    of
    the
    people
    while
    a
    corrupt
    elite
    looted
    with
    impunity.
    •he
    turned
    ZANU-PF
    into
    a
    personal
    fiefdom,
    disregarding
    its
    founding
    values.

3.
During
November
2017,
we
risked
everything

our
lives,
our
freedom,our
futures

to
restore
and
defend
our
legacy,
the
Party
and
the
Constitution

4.
Today,
history
is
repeating
itself
in
the
most
shameful
way
Comrade
President.
Why
we
find
ourselves
in
this
situation
is
both
shocking
and
shameful.

5.
Comrade
President,
on
several
occasions
and
even
abroad,
you
have
informed
the
nation
that
you
are
a
Constitutionalist
and
yet
it
is
now
clear
for
anyone
to
see
that
the
so-called
2030
Agenda
to
extend
your
term
of
office
is
real
and
alive,
and
this
has
now
taken
us
back
to
the
ills
that
led
us
to
November
2017.

6.
Moreover,
the
drivers
of
this
so-called
2030
Agenda
have
now
made
corruption,
looting
of
our
state
coffers
and
bribery
of
our
structures
the
cornerstone
of
their
contribution
to
this
campaign,
and
this
is
now
destroying
our
Party
and
violating
our
Constitution.

7.
We
are
witnessing
in
shock
as
some
of
our
officials
in
the
Party
and
Government
have
now
become
a
law
unto
themselves
and
are
even
announcing
to
our
people
at
gatherings
that
we
are
no
longer
holding
elections
in
2028.
These
are
critical
announcements
on
matters
that
we
as
a
Presidium
and
the
Central
Committee
have
never
discussednor
did
we
pass
a
resolution
at
the
last
2022
Congress.

8.
The
reality
which
is
clearly
emerging
is
that
this
2030
Agenda
is
being
funded
and
driven
by
known
criminals
who
have
brazenly
looted
our
state
coffers
with
impunity
and
are
now
using
these
resources
whose
capture
and
control
of
our
Party
is
unprecedented
and
deeply
worrying.

9.
We
surely
cannot
fold
our
hands
and
watch
these
criminals
like
Kudakwashe
Tagwirei,
Wicknell
Chivhayo,
Scott
Sakupwanya,
and
Delish
Nguwaya,
amongst
others,
structures
and
in
the
process
destroy
our
Party.

10.
Comrade
President,
these
criminals
and
their
associates
have
been
engaged
in
a
brazen
and
systematic
campaign
and
stealing
from
our
Government
and
to
date,
they
have
stolen
more
than
US$3.2
billion
of
Government
funds
through:

  • 10.1
    the
    stealing
    of
    our
    US$1.9
    billion
    from
    the
    Ministry
    of
    Finance
    to
    Kudakwashe
    Tagwirei
    for
    selling
    a
    35%
    stake
    in
    Kuvimba
    Mining
    House.
  • 10.2
    the
    stealing
    of
    state
    assets
    like
    Sandawana
    Mines
    and
    the
    Zimbabwe
    Defence
    Forces’
    Great
    Dyke
    Investments
    by
    Kudakwashe
    Tagwirei,
    and
    inclusion
    of
    these
    assets
    in
    his
    fraudulent
    stealing
    of
    our
    US$1.9
    billion.
  • 10.3
    the
    stealing
    and
    concealment
    by
    Kudakwashe
    Tagwirei
    of
    the
    Party’s
    45%
    shareholding
    in
    Sakunda
    Holdings
    held
    by
    Mvuto
    Investments
    (Private)
    Limited,
    an
    investment
    vehicle
    of
    the
    Party
    held
    through
    our
    National
    Reconstruction
    Group,
    which
    was
    purchased
    in
    November
    2013.
  • 10.4
    the
    stealing
    by
    Wicknell
    Chivhayo
    of
    US$45
    million
    of
    our
    money
    from
    the
    Zimbabwe
    Election
    Commission.
  • 10.5
    the
    stealing
    by
    Wicknell
    Chivhayo
    of
    state
    funds
    more
    than
    US$193
    million
    from
    our
    government
    coffers
    through
    one
    bank
    in
    our
    country
    and
    we
    know
    that
    he
    has
    stolen
    some
    horrific
    amounts
    from
    our
    Government
    coffers
    through
    other
    banks
    in
    our
    country.
  • 10.6
    the
    stealing
    of
    more
    than
    US$800
    million
    from
    Government
    coffers
    by
    Scott
    Sakupwanya
    through
    the
    so-called
    gold
    incentive
    scheme,
    which
    has
    now
    been
    made
    into
    a
    tollgate
    fraud.
  • 10.7
    the
    stealing
    of
    US$162
    million
    of
    public
    funds
    by
    Delish
    Nguwaya
    through
    his
    irregular
    and
    inflated
    Geo
    Pomona
    contract
    with
    the
    City
    of
    Harare.
  • 10.8
    the
    stealing
    of
    more
    than
    US$60
    million
    of
    Government
    funds
    by
    Delish
    Nguwaya
    through
    his
    irregular
    and
    inflated
    Clean
    Planet
    Resources
    contract
    with
    the
    Ministry
    of
    Health/NatPharm.

11.
The
actions
of
these
criminals,
which
also
include
turning
your
Private
office,
Comrade
President,
into
a
place
where
key
Government
decisions
are
made,
demand
that
strong
action
be
taken
immediately
to
preserve
our
Party
and
stability
in
our
Country.

12.
Comrade
President,
we
discussed
issues
around
the
Land
Tenure
Implementation
Committee
and
we
as
a
Presidium
and
Cabinet
appointed
the
Party
Chairman,
Comrade
Muchinguri
to
lead
this
process
and
report
back
on
how
best
we
can
approach
this
but
to
our
shock
and
disbelief,
Kudakwashe
Tagwirei
is
now
running
with
this
and
reversing
the
Land
Reform
Program,
completely
going
against
the
resolutions
we
made
at
the
2022
Congress.

13.
Furthermore,
Comrade
President,
these
criminals
have
polluted
the
concept
of
Affiliates
that
we
set
up
to
support
the
Party.
The
clear
intentions
that
we
had
of
how
these
Affiliates
should
complement
the
Party
have
now
been
completely
hijacked
by
these
criminals,
and
we
are
now
seeing
Affiliates
being
more
resourced
and
becoming
more
powerful
and
influential
than
our
Organs
of
the
Party.

14.
Comrade
President,
you
recall
I
brought
to
your
attention
the
treasonous
project
which
has
been
penned
by
Jonathan
Moyo
for
our
Parliament
to
implement,
the
so-called
Breaking
Barriers
Initiativewhich
is
seeking
to
change
our
political
system
and
suspend
elections
to
2035.
Not
only
is
this
Project
treasonous
and
a
huge
scandal,
and
its
being
done
and
championed
by
people
like
Jonathan
Moyo,
whom
we
fired
from
the
Party.
This
Breaking
Barriers
Initiative
has
also
never
been
discussed
and
approved
at
the
Party’s
last
Congress,
nor
has
it
ever
been
discussed
and
approved
by
the
Central
Committee.
We
are
now
watching
in
shock
and
disbelief
as
this
project
is
now
being
covertly
implemented
and
being
funded
by
these
criminals,
Kudakwashe
Tagwirei,
Wicknell
Chivhayo,
Scott
Sakupwanya,
and
Delish
Nguwaya,
and
their
associates.

15.
Comrade
President,
tirikuti
vanhu
ava,
Kudakwashe
Tagwirei,Wicknell
Chivhayo,
Scott
Sakupwanya,
and
Delish
Nguwaya,
and
their
associates,
ngavasungwe,
immediately
for
these
unprecedented
crimes
they
have
committed.

16.
Tingarambe
takatarisa
vanhu
vachiba
more
than
US$3.2
billion
in
cash
from
our
state
coffers
while
our
people
are
suffering
out
there?
Even
mealie
meal
is
now
running
out
because
of
maize
shortages
while
we
are
prioritising
paying
these
criminals,
ma
hospitals
are
running
out
of
critical
medicines
and
now
the
same
people
who
are
stealing
our
assets
and
resources
are
now
using
these
resources
to
hijack
power,
corrupt
our
structures
and
destroy
our
Party?

17.
Comrade
President,
the
time
for
silence
and
inaction
is
over,
and
we
cannot
allow
these
criminals
who
have
stolen
from
our
Government
coffers
and
our
Party
to
start
using
the
same
resources
to
bribe
fellow
comrades
and
our
structures
to
get
their
support,
defend
and
protect
them.

18.
These
criminals
are
not
just
enriching
themselves;
they
are
using
their
stolen
wealth
to
capture
our
Party,
manipulate
state
institutions,
and
compromise
key
officials.
They
are
creating
a
parallel
power
structure
funded
by
the
very
state
they
are
destroying.
This
cannot
be
tolerated
for
a
single
day
longer.

19.
The
time
for
silence
and
inaction
is
over,
Comrade
President.
We,
as
the
Party’s
Presidium,
have
serious
issues
to
immediately
deal
with
that
will
define
our
future,
and
we
must
immediately
prioritise
cleaning
our
house,
reclaim
our
State
and
our
Party
from
the
capture
by
Kudakwashe
Tagwirei,
Wicknell
Chivhayo,
Scott
Sakupwanya,
and
Delish
Nguwaya
and
their
associates.
We
need
to
reaffirm
the
sacred
principles
of
the
revolution
and
our
legacy,
the
future
of
our
nation,
and
the
faith
of
our
people
depend
on
the
decisive
actions
we
take
now.

20.
I
submit
Comrade
President.

Zimbabwe’s untouchables: A signature, a bribe and a blind eye 

On
a
hot
summer
morning,
I
sat
for
a
bit
watching
a
black-headed
heron
sifting
through
the
golden
stubble
of
a
newly
harvested
crop.
It
was
a
beautiful
day:
a
deep
blue
sky,
very
little
wind,
and
trees
alive
with
birds.
I
lingered
a
while,
letting
the
peace
and
beauty
soak
in,
gathering
my
wits
to
face
the
whispers
of
what
I
suspected
lay
ahead.

Zimbabwe
is
being
chipped
away,
one
shovel
at
a
time,
one
excavator
scoop
at
a
time,
one
mine
truck
at
a
time.
It’s
the
second
land
invasion,
people
say

but
is
that
really
what’s
going
on,
or
is
it
really
the
orgy
of
self-enrichment,
corruption,
and
plundering
by
people
in
positions
of
power
and
authority?

On
a
14km
stretch
of
road
just
beyond
Darwendale
village,
most
signs
of
normal
life
are
gone.
No
sign
of
farms,
crops,
villages
or
homes.

This
14km
stretch
of
road
leading
to
the
boundary
with
National
Parks’
Darwendale
Dam
is
an
ugly,
scarred
wasteland.

Huge
mine
dump
trucks
loaded
with
soil
and
rocks
roar
across
the
plains
leavings
clouds
of
red
dust
in
their
wake.

They
don’t
slow
down
as
they
reach
the
tar
road

so
watch
out,
because
these
are
the
untouchables.

The
Chinese
are
mining
here
and
their
chrome
pits,
trenches,
and
mounds
of
black
soil,
red
soil
and
rocks
stretch
as
far
as
the
eye
can
see
on
both
sides
of
the
road.


The
devastation
is
everywhere

Across
the
plains,
up
the
hillsides,
and
even
underneath
the
main
electricity
pylons
feeding
the
national
grid,
the
devastation
is
everywhere.
An
excavator
is
at
work
up
a
steep
hill,
swinging
its
long
arm
again
and
again
as
it
scrapes
up
our
precious
earth
and
dumps
it
into
waiting
trucks,
suffocating
dust
hanging
in
our
beautiful
blue
sky.

The
sight
of
it
makes
you
heartsore,
so
heartsore.

A
couple
of
brave
souls
are
trying
to
graze
their
cattle
among
the
abandoned
mounds
of
rocks
and
between
the
trenches,
but
it’s
a
treacherous
place.

People
say
that
when
a
cow
or
calf
falls
into
one
of
the
pits
or
trenches,
they
get
stuck
or
break
their
legs
and
there
is
no
way
to
get
them
out.

A
woman
tells
me
that
when
the
Chinese
do
their
blasting
at
night,
the
explosions
shake
their
windows
and
crack
the
walls
of
their
houses
2km
away.
“It’s
awful,
so
awful,”
she
says,
“everything
has
been
completely
destroyed.
These
people
don’t
care.
No
one
can
stop
them.”

You
can
see
the
march
of
the
Chinese
and
their
yellow
excavators
along
this
14km
stretch
of
road
by
the
trail
of
destruction
they
leave
behind.

There
is
no
sign
anywhere
of
any
attempt
at
reclamation
of
the
land. They
dig
their
holes,
pits
and
trenches,
extract
our
minerals,
and
then
leave,
doing
nothing
to
fill
holes,
flatten
mounds
or
re-establish
vegetation.

Take
this
picture
and
replicate
it
in
Hwange,
Mutoko,
Shamva,
Makoni,
Haruni,
Magunje,
Chihota,
Mazowe,
Chiadzwa,
Uzumba
and
so
many
other
places.
Take
it
into
mountains
and
escarpments
such
as
at
Boterekwa
in
Shurugwi,
the
Muvaradonha
Wilderness
in
Muzarabani,
and
now
even
in
Christmas
Pass.
Nowhere
is
safe
from
the
mining
scourge
now.


Who’s
to
blame?

It’s
easy
to
blame
the
Chinese
miners,
who
have
a
bad
human
rights
track
record
in
Zimbabwe

but
the
real
question
is:
how
are
they
getting
away
with
it,
why
are
they
untouchable,
who
is
protecting
them?

Former
energy
minister
Fortune
Chasi
this
week
spilled
the
beans.

“Local
officials
sign
the
licences,
local
elites
pocket
the
‘facilitation
fees’,
local
silence
allows
rivers
to
turn
into
sludge,”
he
said.

“Every
destroyed
riverbed
tells
a
local
story,
a
signature,
a
bribe,
a
blind
eye

This
isn’t
a
‘Chinese
problem.’
It
is
a
governance
problem
… The
Chinese
did
not
destroy
our
mountains
and
rivers.
Our
signatures
did.”

Stark
honesty
from
an
ex-minister,
but
it’s
a
shame
he
didn’t
say
it
when
he
was
still
in
office.


Long-term
loss

But
it’s
not
just
the
pits,
mounds
and
trenches
in
Darwendale,
or
the
sludge
in
rivers;
it’s
the
cyanide
and
mercury
poisoning
our
rivers
and
devastating
aquatic,
bird
and
wild
life;
the
long-term
soil
contamination,
the
loss
of
biodiversity
and
habitat,
and
the
widespread
erosion,
siltation
and
pollution.

Everywhere
communities
are
losing
their
ancestral
homelands
and
being
silenced
with
short-term,
cheap
‘compensation’
such
as
a
fence
or
a
pump
or
a
few
dirty
dollars.

Long
after
the
Chinese
miners
have
left
we
will
all
feel
the
effects
of
this
out-of-control
mining.

While
people
say
nothing,
do
nothing,
and
look
the
other
way
our
beautiful
country
is
being
torn
apart,
ravaged,
looted
and
destroyed
by
the
untouchables,
and
by
those
in
power
in
Zimbabwe
who
give
them
permission
to
do
so.

Please
use
your
voice
to
share
this
news
and
help
us
to
stop
this
before
it’s
too
late.

©
Cathy
Buckle

Travel Turmoil Impacts Africa, Including Zimbabwe, Botswana, and South Africa, as Emirates, Fastjet, Delta, and Other Airlines Suspend 12 Flights, Disrupting Passengers Across Johannesburg and Harare


Travel
turmoil
is
sweeping
across Africa,
leaving
passengers
stranded
and
frustrated.
The
recent suspension
of
12
flights
 by
major
airlines
such
as EmiratesFastjetDelta,
and
others
has
caused
widespread
disruptions.
This
chaos
is
particularly
affecting
travelers
in ZimbabweBotswana,
and South
Africa
,
with Johannesburg and Harare seeing
the
worst
of
the
delays.

These
suspensions
come
at
a
time
when
air
travel
is
already
challenging,
further
complicating
the
situation.
The
impacts
are
felt
not
only
in
the
cities
of
Johannesburg
and
Harare
but
throughout
Africa,
with
people
struggling
to
navigate
the
confusion.
As
the
disruption
continues,
many
are
left
waiting
for
updates
on
when
normal
service
will
resume.

Affected
Cities
and
Airports

The
affected
several
key
cities
and
airports
in
Africa. Johannesburg is
represented
by OR
Tambo
International
Airport
 in
South
Africa,
a
major
hub
for
both
domestic
and
international
flights. Harare is
represented
by Harare
International
Airport
 in
Zimbabwe,
another
significant
airport
for
air
travel
in
the
region.
Additionally,
the
table
includes Ivato
International
Airport
 in Antananarivo,
Madagascar,
which
serves
as
the
main
gateway
for
international
travel
to
and
from
the
country.
These
airports,
located
in
prominent
African
cities,
play
crucial
roles
in
connecting
passengers
across
the
continent
and
beyond,
with
many
airlines
experiencing
disruptions
that
have
impacted
travelers
in
these
areas.

Flight
Cancellations


Airport

Airline

Cancelled
(Flights)

Delayed
(Flights)

OR
Tambo
Int’l
Air
Zimbabwe
2 0
Air
Botswana
1 2
Delta
Air
Lines
1 0
South
African
Airlink
1 81

Harare
International
Fastjet
Zimbabwe
2 4
Air
Zimbabwe
2 0

Ivato
Int’l
Emirates 2 0
Air
France
1 0

Affected
Airlines

The
affected
several
notable
airlines
that
operate
in
Africa
and
internationally.
These
include Air
Zimbabwe
,
the
national
carrier
of
Zimbabwe,
and Air
Botswana
,
which
serves
Botswana. Delta
Air
Lines
,
a
major
U.S.-based
airline,
also
features
in
the
table,
along
with South
African
Airlink
,
a
regional
airline
serving
South
Africa.
Additionally, Fastjet
Zimbabwe
 provides
low-cost
services
within
Zimbabwe,
while Emirates,
based
in
the
United
Arab
Emirates,
operates
globally.
Lastly, Air
France
,
a
prominent
European
airline,
is
also
listed,
offering
international
flights
to
and
from
Africa.
These
airlines
play
a
significant
role
in
connecting
various
parts
of
Africa
with
the
rest
of
the
world.

Overview
of
Flight
Cancellations

The
flight
cancellations
highlighted
significant
disruptions
in
air
travel
across
key
airports
in
Africa.
At OR
Tambo
International
Airport
 in
Johannesburg,
South
Africa,
multiple
airlines
such
as Air
Zimbabwe
Air
Botswana
Delta
Air
Lines
,
and South
African
Airlink
 are
experiencing
cancellations.
Notably, Air
Zimbabwe
 saw
2
canceled
flights,
with
all
of
its
scheduled
flights
disrupted,
while South
African
Airlink
 had
a
notable
81
delayed
flights,
though
only
1
flight
was
canceled.
The
highest
flight
cancellation
comes
from Air
Zimbabwe
,
which
had
2
canceled
flights,
representing
100%
of
its
scheduled
flights.
In Harare
International
Airport
 (Zimbabwe), Fastjet
Zimbabwe
 canceled
2
flights,
impacting
the
region’s
connectivity.
Furthermore, Ivato
International
Airport
 in Antananarivo,
Madagascar,
had Emirates and Air
France
 with
no
delayed
flights,
but Emirates saw
2
flights
canceled,
causing
disruption
for
passengers.
These
cancellations
indicate
broader
challenges
facing
African
aviation,
affecting
both
domestic
and
international
connectivity.

What
to
Do
if
Your
Flight
Gets
Cancelled:
A
Quick
Guide

Flight
cancellations
can
be
frustrating,
but
knowing
the
right
steps
to
take
can
help
minimize
stress.
Here’s
what
you
can
do
if
you
find
yourself
in
this
situation:


Stay
Updated

Monitor
your
email,
phone,
and
the
airline’s
app
for
rebooking
confirmation
or
further
announcements.


Stay
Calm
and
Check
for
Updates

As
soon
as
you
learn
your
flight
is
canceled,
stay
calm
and
check
for
updates.
Many
airlines
will
notify
you
via
text,
email,
or
their
app.
Visit
the
airline’s
website
for
real-time
updates
on
the
situation.


Contact
the
Airline

Reach
out
to
the
airline’s
customer
service
either
in
person
at
the
airport
or
over
the
phone.
If
you’re
at
the
airport,
head
to
the
service
desk.
If
you’re
not,
try
calling
or
using
the
airline’s
online
chat
system
to
avoid
waiting
in
long
queues.


Know
Your
Rights

Familiarize
yourself
with
the
airline’s
policies
regarding
cancellations.
Many
airlines
offer
rebooking
options
or
compensation,
especially
if
the
cancellation
is
within
their
control.
In
the
EU,
for
example,
passengers
are
entitled
to
compensation
under
certain
conditions.


Consider
Alternative
Flights

Ask
the
airline
about
the
next
available
flight.
If
you
can’t
find
a
suitable
option,
consider
booking
a
new
flight
through
another
airline,
or
check
for
other
forms
of
transport
like
trains
or
buses.

While
airlines
strive
to
manage
operations
effectively,
external
factors
and
internal
challenges
continue
to
affect
service
reliability.
Passengers
are
encouraged
to
stay
informed,
plan
ahead,
and
maintain
flexibility
when
traveling
in
the
region.

Source:


Travel
Turmoil
Impacts
Africa,
Including
Zimbabwe,
Botswana,
and
South
Africa,
as
Emirates,
Fastjet,
Delta,
and
Other
Airlines
Suspend
12
Flights,
Disrupting
Passengers
Across
Johannesburg
and
Harare


Travel
And
Tour
World

Post
published
in:

Featured

Zimbabwe Vigil Diary 11th October 2025


13.10.2025


18:50

Another
virtual
Vigil
today
continues
our
protest
against
the
human
rights
abuse
and
lack
of
democracy
in
Zimbabwe. 



https://www.flickr.com/photos/zimbabwevigil/54849497833/sizes/m/


 

Our
virtual
Vigil
activists
today
were
Tanyaradzi
Daka,
Anna
Katsande,
Trish
Paidamoyo
Matsikira
and
Melody
Mkwenje.
They
carried
placards
expressing
their
dissatisfaction
with
ZANU
PF,
Zimbabwe’s
ruling
regime.  Photos:https://www.flickr.com/photos/zimbabwevigil/albums/72177720329619217.

For
Vigil
pictures
check: http://www.flickr.com/photos/zimbabwevigil/.
Please
note:
Vigil
photos
can
only
be
downloaded
from
our
Flickr
website.


 


Events
and
Notices:  


  • Next
    Vigil
    meeting
    outside
    the
    Zimbabwe
    Embassy. 
    Saturday
    18th October
    from
    2

    5
    pm.
    We
    meet
    on
    the
    first
    and
    third
    Saturdays
    of
    every
    month.
    On
    other
    Saturdays
    the
    virtual
    Vigil
    will
    run.

  • The
    Restoration
    of
    Human
    Rights
    in
    Zimbabwe
    (ROHR)
     is
    the
    Vigil’s
    partner
    organisation
    based
    in
    Zimbabwe.
    ROHR
    grew
    out
    of
    the
    need
    for
    the
    Vigil
    to
    have
    an
    organisation
    on
    the
    ground
    in
    Zimbabwe
    which
    reflected
    the
    Vigil’s
    mission
    statement
    in
    a
    practical
    way.
    ROHR
    in
    the
    UK
    actively
    fundraises
    through
    membership
    subscriptions,
    events,
    sales
    etc
    to
    support
    the
    activities
    of
    ROHR
    in
    Zimbabwe.

  • The
    Vigil’s
    book
    ‘Zimbabwe
    Emergency’
     is
    based
    on
    our
    weekly
    diaries.
    It
    records
    how
    events
    in
    Zimbabwe
    have
    unfolded
    as
    seen
    by
    the
    diaspora
    in
    the
    UK.
    It
    chronicles
    the
    economic
    disintegration,
    violence,
    growing
    oppression
    and
    political
    manoeuvring

    and
    the
    tragic
    human
    cost
    involved. It
    is
    available
    at
    the
    Vigil.
    All
    proceeds
    go
    to
    the
    Vigil
    and
    our
    sister
    organisation
    the
    Restoration
    of
    Human
    Rights
    in
    Zimbabwe’s
    work
    in
    Zimbabwe.
    The
    book
    is
    also
    available
    from
    Amazon.


  • Facebook
    pages:   


        Vigil : 
https ://www.facebook.com/zimbabwevigil 


        
ROHR: https://www.facebook.com/Restoration-of-Human-Rights-ROHR-Zimbabwe-International-370825706588551/

ZAF: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Zimbabwe-Action-Forum-ZAF/490257051027515

The
Vigil,
outside
the
Zimbabwe
Embassy,
429
Strand,
London
meets
regularly
on
Saturdays
from
14.00
to
17.00
to
protest
against
gross
violations
of
human
rights
in
Zimbabwe.
The
Vigil
which started
in
October
2002
will
continue
until
internationally-monitored,
free
and
fair
elections
are
held
in
Zimbabwe.

Post
published
in:

Featured

ZANU PF Warns Delegates Against Heckling Leaders At Upcoming Conference

The
warning
comes
amid
social
media
reports
suggesting
that
some
party
members
may
plan
to
heckle
Vice
President
Constantino
Chiwenga
during
the
event,
as
debates
over
succession
continue
to
intensify.

Chiwenga
was
heckled
at
the
National
Heroes
Acre
during
the
burial
of
national
hero
Justin
Mupamhanga
on
27
January
2025.

Information
Technology
Minister
Tatenda
Mavetera,
leading
the
Young
Women
4
ED
group
aligned
with
Mnangagwa,
led
chants
targeting
Chiwenga.

They
sang
“mupanduki
mupanduki
chera
mwena
nguva
yakwana”

which
translates
to
“sellout,
sellout,
dig
a
hole,
the
time
has
come”.

Chiwenga
is
widely
seen
as
the
frontrunner
to
succeed
President
Emmerson
Mnangagwa
in
2028,
when
his
second
term
expires,
although
Mnangagwa’s
loyalists
are
pushing
for
an
extension
of
his
tenure
to
2030.

ZANU
PF
Director
of
Communications,
Farai
Marapira,
stressed
that
the
National
People’s
Conference
is
a
formal
meeting
of
delegates,
leaving
no
room
for
heckling.
He
said:

“We
are
not
going
to
a
rally.
We
are
going
to
a
conference.
This
is
not
a
free-for-all.
This
is
a
meeting
of
delegates.
This
is
a
meeting
of
leadership.
There
is
no
time
to
heckle.

“This
is
just
once
again
social
media
trying
its
best
to
push
agendas
on
us
as
ZANU-PF.
But,
of
course,
it
will
fail.”

In
recent
days,
social
media
has
been
flooded
with
claims
that
ZANU
PF
youths
are
being
bused
to
Mutare
in
Manicaland
province
with
the
sole
purpose
of
booing
Chiwenga.

Marapira
dismissed
such
reports,
saying
those
promoting
the
claims
are
ignorant
of
the
party’s
internal
procedures.
He
said:

“This
issue
of
being
bused
to
boo,
how
are
they
going
to
enter
when
they
are
not
accredited?
We
are
not
accrediting
crowds,
we
are
accrediting
delegates.

“This
is
mischief
being
created
by
people
who
are
ignorant
of
the
ways
of
the
party
and
how
it
conducts
its
conferences.”

The
alleged
plans
to
heckle
Chiwenga
come
as
the
Vice
President
has
repeatedly
spoken
out
against
corruption,
which
he
describes
as
a
threat
to
national
security.

He
has
consistently
condemned
“zvigananda”,
a
term
meaning
leeches,
referring
to
individuals
who
flaunt
wealth
acquired
through
the
siphoning
of
public
resources
via
inflated
government
tenders.

The trouble with Zanu PF’s Resolution Number 1

A
YEAR
ago,
at
its
annual
Conference,
Zanu
PF
passed
the
notorious
Resolution
No.
1.
The
resolution,
a
vulgar
piece
of
unmitigated
buffoonery,
attempts
to
extend
President
Emmerson
Mnangagwa’s
tenure
beyond
the
term
fixed
by
congress
in
2022
and
effectively
calls
for
subverting
the
national
constitution
to
achieve
that
end.

The
measure
is
both
egregious
and
unlawful,
chiefly
because
it
conflicts
with
Zanu
PF’s
own
constitutive
instruments.


Congress
v
Conference

Zanu
PF’s
congress,
which
meets
once
every
five
years,
is
the
party’s
supreme
decision‑making
body.

Depending
on
which
of
the
three
un-ratified
2022
constitutions
one
reads,
this
authority
is
set
out
in
section
23
or
27
in
materially
similar
terms.
The
provision
confers
on
congress
the
following
powers:


“Congress
shall
be
the
supreme
policy
making
organ
of
the
Party
and
shall
have
the
following
powers
and
functions:-


(1)
to
elect
the
President
and
First
Secretary
of
the
Party,
who
shall
automatically
become
the
sole
candidate
of
the
State
President
in
the
ensuing
elections;”

In
accordance
with
this
provision,
congress
in
2022
elected
Mnangagwa
as
Zanu
PF’s
candidate
for
the
2023
elections.
This
election
was
for
a
five-year
period.

By
design,
congress
is
the
body
that
meets
to
select
the
party’s
candidate
for
any
general
elections
and
Mnangagwa’s
incumbency
draws
its
lifeblood
from
the
2022
congress
resolution.
No
Zanu
PF
member
can
seek
or
maintain
state
or
party
power
as
the
president
post
2028
without
the
authority
of
congress.

Two
points
emerge
and
must
detain
me:


the
party
constitution
is
tailored
so
that
congress
precedes
a
general
election
for
the
purpose
of
selecting
a
presidential
candidate;
and


as
a
contractual
and
constitutional
instrument,
the
party
constitution
cannot
validly
contain
provisions
that
conflict
with
the
national
constitution
and
any
such
conflicting
provision
is
void.

Thus,
there
is
no
valid
basis
within
Zanu
PF’s
constitution
for
declaring
a
candidate
beyond
the
2028
elections
more
so
if
this
is
coming
from
an
organ
inferior
to
congress.
Any
attempt
to
do
so
would
violate
the
party’s
own
constitution
and
would
subordinate
congress
to
the
Mai
Welly-twerking-transactional
politics
that
we
now
see
on
display

The
national
conference
meets
annually
and
its
powers
include
receiving
central
committee
reports,
reviewing
implementation
of
central
committee
programmes,
making
resolutions
for
implementation
by
the
central
committee
declaring
the
president
elected
at
congress
as
the
party’s
state
presidential
candidate.

Outside
a
determination
made
by
congress
and
that
only
for
a
period
of
five
years,
the
national
conference
cannot
transact
any
business
bearing
on
the
question
of
a
national
leader
as
is
the
purport
of
Resolution
1.

Crucially,
the
national
conference
does
not
have
the
power
to
elect
the
party’s
presidential
candidate;
it
can
only
declare
an
election
already
made
by
congress.

Last
year’s
conference
resolution
purporting
to
elect
or
rather
select
Mnangagwa
for
a
period
outside
that
fixed
by
congress,
and
calling
for
subversion
of
congress’s
decision
to
achieve
the
purpose,
was
therefore
unlawful
under
any
of
the
three
constitutional
texts
that
are
fraudulently
used
by
Zanu
PF.

Mnangagwa’s
position
is
not
a
legitimate
matter
for
internal
debate
at
this
year’s
conference.
In
fact
concerned
Zanu
PF
members
can
stop
their
party—either
by
judicial
decree
or
through
legitimate
political
maneuvering—from
becoming
engaged
with
this
issue.

Put
in
very
simple
terms,
the
question
of
the
possible
extension
of
Mnangagwa’s
position
cannot
be
debated
by
the
national
conference.
It
is
an
act
ultra
vires.

Zanu
PF
must
abide
by
its
own
rules
and
by
the
national
constitution.
It
cannot
lawfully
transact
business
in
breach
of
those
instruments
or
call
for
their
subversion.
This
festival
of
absurdities
and
illegality
must
be
stopped.

The
men
within
Zanu
PF,
if
there
be
any
(not
vanoda
kuchengeta
vana),
should
confront
these
breaches
and
insist
on
adherence
to
both
the
party
constitution
and
the
constitution
of
the
land.



Thabani
Mpofu
is
an
advocate
in
Zimbabwe’s
superior
courts